Lessons learned from the ashes
Tuesday, April 12, 2011 at 4:03PM "If we teach today as we taught yesterday, we rob our children of tomorrow." -John Dewey
I saw this quote on an educational technology blog, and it made me pause. When working with teachers, I see two different types of teacher: type one - those who are constantly trying different ways to reach the student and type two - those who teach the same way everyday, most likely mimicking the teachers of their childhood classrooms.
I also think back to when I taught. When I first started, I was type two. I taught the way I was taught, and for the first few years taught the same thing the same way every year. I’ve often said to new teachers or student teachers that if I could, I would write a letter of apology to the students I taught in the first five years of my career. I took the “don’t smile until Christmas” advice a little too literally, and I definitely had what I was teaching pre-planned and ready to go no matter what.
Two things occurred to change me as a teacher. The first event opened my eyes to the value of what I had my students completing under the guise of learning. Because I was taught literature a certain way, I had the elaborate project list, similar to what my own teachers gave me, ready for my unsuspecting students. We were studying Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Julius Caesar. I’m sure most of you remember this from your own days in a high school classroom.
My students not only read the play, but they had to memorize every detail of Shakespeare’s life right down to the number of children he had and how many died…everything you ever needed to know to become a Jeopardy champion. If that wasn’t enough, they also had to know every detail of Shakespeare’s theater. To ensure that they not only had to memorize these facts that did nothing to instill a love of Shakespeare’s writing, they had to construct a model of Shakespeare’s Globe. After several years of this exact lesson that soon became a rite of passage for MCHS sophomores (that and yes, The Good Earth. But that is another story), I had the pleasure of having a student who opened my eyes and made me look at myself.
The day the projects were due, my room was filled with beautiful, and not-so-beautiful, models of the Globe. In walks this particular student with a small box. When it came his time to present his Globe (yes, we actually sat through every student naming the parts of his/her Globe), he went to the front of the room and presented his box filled with ashes. He proudly stated (with a sly grin on his face), that this was “The Globe after it burned to the ground.”
I admit, I wasn’t sure how to react, and he obviously wasn’t sure how I would react because he quickly went out to the hallway and brought in his actual Globe. What he may not realize is that his box of ashes made me rethink how I taught. It wasn’t a change that occurred right away, but I did start reflecting on the value of what assignments I gave students. I won’t say I never gave another lame assignment, because I’m sure I did, but I will say that I never taught things exactly the same way twice because I looked at the value of every lesson and where each class was and needed to go. The days of the cookie cutter lesson that I could pull out of the file cabinet were gone.
The second event that changed me as a teacher was having my own children. It made me realize that every student was once someone’s beloved baby, and every one of them is different. I became much kinder and willing to see the individual instead of the class. My file cabinet of lessons became something that seldom was opened. My lessons were catered to the class in front of me, not what I always did and the way I always did it.
This brings me back to the quote “If we teach today as we taught yesterday, we rob our children of tomorrow.” Can we teach the same thing, the same way, day after day and expect our students to be ready for tomorrow? Obviously, the answer is no. If you are a teacher and are reading this, then I challenge you. I challenge you to think about your lessons and ask why. Why am I giving this assignment? What do I want my students to understand and be able to do once this lesson is over? Is it something that will prepare them for the future or is it something that I needed to be prepared for my future? Because, honestly, theirs is a very different future, and building that Globe model probably isn’t going to get them where we need them to be.
As a teacher, you should reflect and recharge your lessons. Think about where our students today need to be in five, ten, fifteen years. Don’t be satisfied with what you’ve always done; instead, learn new ways to reach every child. The way we’ve always done it may not work. We all need to be willing to see the real value in the box of ashes.
MCPS | Comments Off | 






